Q&A: Common Association Finance Challenges

Associations and dues-based organizations operate under a financial model that comes with its own set of challenges. Revenue may depend heavily on membership, events, sponsorships, or grants, while spending decisions often need to balance the organization’s mission with its long-term financial health.

To discuss some of the financial questions association leaders commonly face, we spoke with Kirsten Houghton, CPA, MBA, Principal at SVA Certified Public Accountants.

FAQs About Common Association Challenges

In this Q&A, Kirsten discusses revenue diversification, budgeting, reserve planning, financial oversight, internal controls, and the role financial advisors can play in helping associations build greater resilience.

What makes association finances different from those of a traditional business?

One of the biggest differences is the membership-driven revenue model. Many associations rely on dues as a major source of income, which means their financial results can be closely tied to membership retention, renewals, and the value members believe they receive from the organization.

Associations may also have restricted funds that can only be used for designated purposes. Having cash available doesn’t always mean that all of it is available for general operations.

What are some of the biggest financial risks facing associations today?

Membership changes can be a major concern. Declining membership, an aging member base, or difficulty attracting the next generation of members can affect dues revenue and participation in programs.

Event revenue can also fluctuate from year to year. Attendance, sponsorships, travel costs, and broader economic conditions can all influence whether an event performs as expected.

RELATED CONTENT: BIZ TIP

READING BETWEEN THE LINES OF INTERPRETING NONPROFIT FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

OPEN IN NEW WINDOW

Why can relying too heavily on membership dues be risky?

When a large share of an association’s revenue comes from one source, changes to that source can have an outsized effect on the organization.

For example, a decline in membership or an increase in nonrenewals can quickly put pressure on the budget. Economic downturns can also cause individuals or businesses to reconsider memberships and other discretionary spending.

Diversifying revenue can help reduce that concentration. Depending on the organization, other revenue sources may include sponsorships, certifications, educational programming, publications, events, grants, and advertising.

How can associations improve their long-term financial sustainability?

Start with strategic planning. Financial planning should connect to where the association wants to go over the next several years, including anticipated programs, staffing needs, technology investments, and other priorities.

Revenue diversification can also provide more flexibility when one source underperforms. At the same time, associations should regularly review costs and determine whether resources are being directed toward programs and activities that support their goals.

Reserve policies and investment oversight are also part of the conversation. Associations need a plan for what reserves are intended to cover, when they may be used, and how funds that are not needed for immediate operations will be managed.

Should associations depend on dues as their primary revenue source?

Dues may remain the largest revenue source for many associations, and that can be appropriate depending on the organization. The bigger question is how dependent the association is on that revenue and what would happen if membership declined.

A healthy revenue mix generally includes sources that complement the association’s mission and member offerings such as event sponsorship, certifications, education and training, publications, and advertising sales are some possibilities.

There is no single revenue mix that works for every association. The goal is to build a model that fits the organization and reduces unnecessary dependence on any one source.

RELATED CONTENT: BIZ TIP

WHAT YOUR NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION'S FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ARE REALLY TELLING YOU

OPEN IN NEW WINDOW

What financial metrics should associations monitor?

Financial statements provide a starting point, but association leaders should also track indicators that show what is happening behind the numbers.

Membership retention and renewal rates can help leaders identify changes in the membership base before those changes have a larger financial impact. Net revenue and operating margin can provide insight into overall financial performance.

Associations should also monitor cash reserves, days cash on hand, and other liquidity measures to understand their ability to meet near-term obligations.

Program and event profitability can be useful as well. Looking at revenue without considering the associated costs may provide an incomplete picture of how a program or event is performing.

The most useful metrics are those reviewed consistently over time. Trends often tell association leaders more than one isolated number.

What makes budgeting difficult for associations?

Many association budgets depend on variables that are difficult to predict. Membership may fluctuate. Event attendance and sponsorship revenue may change. Grant funding may arrive at a different time than anticipated. Restricted funding can limit how certain dollars are used.

A budget should be treated as a management tool rather than a document that is prepared once and put aside. Comparing actual results with the budget throughout the year allows leaders to identify changes earlier and adjust their plans.

How far into the future should associations forecast?

An annual budget is useful for managing the current year, but associations can benefit from looking beyond that twelve-month period.

Rolling forecasts can help update expectations as new information becomes available during the year. Multi-year planning can give boards and management a better view of how current decisions may affect future resources.

Longer-term forecasts are useful when an association is considering significant initiatives such as technology investments, new programs, staffing changes, facility needs, or other commitments that extend beyond one budget cycle.

What role should reserve funds play?

Reserves provide associations with financial flexibility.

Operating reserves may help cover periods when revenue is lower than anticipated or expenses are higher. Capital reserves can be designated for future equipment, facility, or technology needs. An organization may also maintain funds for emergencies or other unexpected circumstances.

The board should establish policies that define the purpose of the reserves, appropriate reserve levels, who can authorize their use, and how the funds should be replenished after they are used.

That framework can help keep reserve decisions consistent even as board members and volunteer leaders change.

How much cash should an association keep in reserve?

There is no single reserve level that applies to every association. A common range to consider is approximately three to twelve months of operating needs, but the appropriate amount depends on the organization. Associations with predictable, recurring revenue may have different needs than those that depend heavily on seasonal events, grants, or other less predictable sources.

Leaders should also consider organizational risk, revenue seasonality, upcoming capital needs, and how quickly the association could adjust expenses if revenue declined.

What financial information should association boards review regularly?

Budget-to-actual results, cash flow, reserve balances, and investment performance when the organization maintains investments will help board members understand current financial performance and emerging trends. Membership trends and relevant financial ratios can provide additional context.

Boards should also consider how the information is presented. Reports should help members identify significant changes, ask informed questions, and understand how financial performance relates to the association’s strategic priorities.

RELATED CONTENT: BIZ TIP

HOW NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS CAN NAVIGATE FEDERAL FUNDING UNCERTAINTY

OPEN IN NEW WINDOW

What are some common financial mistakes association boards make?

One common issue is focusing primarily on the income statement. Revenue and expenses matter, but they don’t tell the full financial story. Cash flow, reserve balances, liquidity, and longer-term trends also deserve attention.

Boards can also run into problems when difficult financial decisions are delayed. If membership or revenue is trending downward, waiting several budget cycles to respond may reduce the options available to the organization. Focusing heavily on the current year without connecting financial decisions to a longer-term strategic plan is also another challenge.

What internal controls should associations have?

Internal controls should be designed around the association’s size, staffing structure, technology, and risk profile.

Segregation of duties is important here. Whenever possible, responsibility for authorizing transactions, handling funds, recording activity, and reconciling accounts should be divided among different people. Associations should also have defined approval processes for expenditures and payments, along with controls designed to reduce fraud risk.

Cybersecurity should be included in the discussion because financial information, member data, payment systems, and vendor relationships can create additional exposure.

Vendor management matters as well. Associations should have procedures for setting up new vendors, approving changes to payment information, and reviewing transactions for unusual activity.

Smaller associations may have fewer employees available to divide responsibilities. In those cases, board or management review can provide an additional layer of oversight.

What should associations look for in an accounting and advisory firm?

Industry experience makes a meaningful difference. Associations have financial, tax, governance, and reporting considerations that differ from many traditional businesses. A firm that regularly works with nonprofit organizations and membership associations is more likely to understand those circumstances.

Leaders should consider the firm’s audit capabilities, tax knowledge, advisory services, technology consulting resources, and ability to communicate with the board.

The relationship should also extend beyond year-end compliance. An advisor who understands the organization can provide perspective on budgeting, financial trends, internal controls, planning, and other issues throughout the year.