How to Evaluate the ROI of Your Dental Practice CPA

Most dental practice owners recognize the need for a CPA. But when evaluating the value of a CPA relationship, looking just at annual fees and tax preparation only tells part of the story.

A strong dental practice CPA can contribute to profitability, tax planning, major business decisions, risk management, and long-term financial goals. While some of that value can be measured in dollars, other benefits are harder to quantify.

The better question for practice owners is: What measurable financial and strategic value is my CPA helping create for my practice?

Start With the Scope of Your CPA Relationship

Before determining ROI, consider what you've actually engaged your CPA to do.

A CPA hired primarily for tax preparation and compliance shouldn't be evaluated against the same expectations as an advisor engaged for year-round financial planning. Depending on the relationship, services may include proactive tax planning, financial analysis, cash flow guidance, entity and compensation planning, acquisition analysis, expansion planning, and practice transition support.

Understanding the scope gives you a better starting point for determining whether you're receiving the level of value you expect.

RELATED CONTENT: BIZ TIP

MAXIMIZING THE VALUE OF YOUR DENTAL PRACTICE

OPEN IN NEW WINDOW

Look at the Impact of Tax Planning

Tax savings are among the easier components of CPA ROI to quantify.

Proactive dental practice tax planning could involve evaluating entity structure, retirement plan opportunities, the timing of income and deductions, capital expenditures, depreciation, and estimated tax payments. The appropriate strategies will depend on the practice and owner's individual circumstances.

One simple calculation is:

Estimated tax savings from planning ÷ annual CPA fees = tax-planning ROI

For example, if planning results in an estimated $15,000 in tax savings and the practice spends $7,500 annually on accounting, tax, and advisory services, those savings alone equal approximately twice the annual CPA fee.

Tax savings shouldn't be considered in isolation, however. The goal is to make sound financial decisions while evaluating the related tax implications, rather than pursuing a tax benefit that doesn't otherwise make business sense.

Evaluate the Effect on Practice Profitability

Receiving financial statements and receiving financial advice aren't necessarily the same thing. Much of the potential value comes from interpreting the numbers and deciding what to do with them.

A CPA familiar with dental practice financial management may help you examine areas such as provider productivity, staffing costs, supplies, laboratory expenses, overhead, operating margins, cash flow, and debt.

Suppose financial analysis identifies a recurring expense trend and changes made by the practice contribute to a $25,000 improvement in annual profitability. That improvement can be considered when evaluating the broader return from the CPA relationship.

Dental practice benchmarks can also provide useful context. Rather than treating benchmarks as rigid targets, use them to ask questions: Where are we outside typical ranges? Why? Is there a reasonable explanation? Is there an opportunity to improve?

Specialty, geography, provider mix, practice size, staffing structure, and growth stage can all influence the answer.

RELATED CONTENT: BIZ TIP

IS YOUR DENTAL PRACTICE READY FOR A SECOND LOCATION?

OPEN IN NEW WINDOW

Consider the Value of Better Business Decisions

Some of the greatest returns from a CPA relationship may come from decisions that happen only occasionally.

Buying or selling a practice, opening another location, purchasing real estate, hiring an associate, adding a partner, taking on significant debt, or planning an ownership transition can involve substantial financial consequences.

An experienced advisor should help you understand cash flow implications, evaluate financing options, analyze tax consequences, structure a transaction, and identify risks before you make a commitment.

A single well-informed decision involving hundreds of thousands of dollars may provide significant value relative to several years of professional fees.

Don't Overlook Risk Reduction

CPA ROI can also include costs that never occur.

Avoiding tax penalties, unexpected liabilities, cash flow problems, poorly structured transactions, compensation issues, or preventable planning mistakes has value even though it can be difficult to assign an exact dollar amount.

This is one reason CPA ROI shouldn't always be reduced to a single percentage. Some outcomes are easier to see after the fact, while good risk management may mean a costly problem never develops in the first place.

Ask How Proactive the Relationship Is

Consider who initiated the most important financial conversations during the past year.

Did your CPA bring tax-planning ideas to you before year-end? Did they flag unusual financial trends? Did they ask about upcoming purchases, hiring plans, growth opportunities, or ownership changes? Did they communicate changes that could affect your practice?

A relationship centered primarily on reporting past activity provides a different level of support than one that also helps you plan ahead.

The level of involvement you should expect also depends on the services included in your engagement. Some practice owners want their CPA focused primarily on tax compliance and reporting, while others choose to invest in more frequent planning, analysis, and advisory support. When evaluating the relationship, make sure your expectations align with the scope of services and fees you’ve agreed upon.

RELATED CONTENT: BIZ TIP

OPTIMIZING REVENUE CYCLE MANAGEMENT FOR DENTAL PRACTICES

OPEN IN NEW WINDOW

Use a CPA ROI Scorecard

Rather than searching for one definitive ROI number, periodically evaluate your CPA across several categories:

Consider rating each area from one to five annually. The exercise can highlight both the value you're receiving and areas where the relationship could improve.

RELATED CONTENT: EGUIDE

MANAGING YOUR DENTAL PRACTICE: A COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE FOR FINANCIAL SUCCESS

OPEN IN NEW WINDOW

Questions to Ask Your CPA

At your next meeting, consider asking:

• What opportunities do you see to improve my practice's financial performance?
• Which financial metrics should I monitor most closely?
• How does my practice compare with relevant dental benchmarks?
• What tax-planning opportunities should we consider before year-end?
• What financial risks might I be overlooking?
• Based on my long-term goals, what should we be planning for now?

For dental practice owners, the annual CPA fee is only one side of the equation. The more meaningful measure is what the relationship contributes to the financial health of the practice and the owner's ability to make informed decisions about what comes next.